Research / is-reading-on-a-screen-worse-than-paper
Is Reading on a Screen Worse Than Paper? What the Research Shows
Yes, but only slightly, and mostly in particular situations. Across dozens of experiments comparing reading on paper with reading on a screen, people understand the same text a little better on paper. A 2018 meta-analysis of 54 studies and more than 171,000 readers put the paper advantage at a small effect size of 0.21. The gap showed up for informational text, such as textbooks, reports and articles, but not for stories. It was also larger when readers were working against the clock.
On tablets and e-readers the gap is about half the size of the earlier, mostly computer-based estimate, and the newer evidence finds no difference between a tablet and an e-reader. So what you read, how fast you read it and what else is on the device matter more than the format alone. Below is what the main reviews found, where they disagree, what it means for children, and how to set up a screen for reading if paper is not practical. If the deeper problem is that you cannot settle into a book at all, how to read books again covers rebuilding that habit.
What the big reviews found
Four meta-analyses, each pooling many separate experiments, point the same way: paper wins on comprehension by a small margin, and the two reviews that measured speed found no difference.
- The largest. Delgado, Vargas, Ackerman and Salmerón (2018), in Educational Research Review, pooled 54 studies published from 2000 to 2017, covering 171,055 participants. Paper beat digital reading with an effect size (Hedges' g) of 0.21, and the result was the same whether different people read in each format or the same people read in both.
- The most selective. Clinton (2019), in the Journal of Research in Reading, included only studies that randomly assigned readers. Across 33 studies, screens had a small, significant negative effect on comprehension. The effect seemed limited to expository (informational) texts, with no difference for narrative ones, and no reliable difference in reading time.
- The smallest. Kong, Seo and Zhai (2018), in Computers and Education, analysed 17 studies and also found better comprehension on paper and no significant difference in reading speed.
- The newest. Salmerón and colleagues (2024), in the Journal of Educational Psychology, looked only at handheld devices. It is covered in its own section below because it changes the advice.
An effect size of 0.21 is small. Roughly, it means the average paper reader scored a little higher than the average screen reader, with a great deal of overlap between the two groups. For one novel read in bed, it is unlikely to matter. For a student revising from screens all term, or for someone signing a contract they read on a phone, a small, consistent disadvantage is worth knowing about.
When paper beats a screen, and when it does not
The gap depends on three things: the type of text, the time pressure and the reader's own judgement.
Informational text, not stories
Both Delgado's and Clinton's reviews found the paper advantage for informational or mixed texts but not for texts that were only narrative. A thriller on a tablet and the same thriller in paperback seem to be understood about equally well. A dense chapter on biology does not.
One small study did find a difference for a story, though only in one specific skill. In a 2019 experiment by Mangen, Olivier and Velay, 50 adults read a 28-page mystery story of about 10,800 words, either on a Kindle DX or in a paperback. The two groups did not differ on reading time, engagement or overall recall. Print readers were better at putting the events of the plot back in order, though, and answered more questions about time and sequence correctly (57.1 per cent against 44.0 per cent). It is one small study with an older Kindle, so treat it as a hint that the physical book helps you keep track of where things happen, not as settled fact.
Time pressure makes it worse
Delgado's review found that the paper advantage grew when reading was timed rather than self-paced. A follow-up experiment by Delgado and Salmerón (2021) in Learning and Instruction tested why. It assigned 140 undergraduates to read on paper or on screen, with or without a time limit. Under time pressure, paper readers' minds wandered less, as if they had tightened their focus, while screen readers' did not change, and screen readers understood the text worse than all the other groups. With unlimited time there was no difference in mind-wandering or comprehension.
The authors read this as evidence that people slip into a shallower, skimming mode on screens when they are rushed. That fits with the gap being widest for timed, informational reading, but it is one experiment, so it explains the pattern plausibly rather than proving it.
You may think you understood more than you did
Clinton's review found that readers judged their own performance more accurately after reading on paper. On screens, people were more likely to overestimate how much they had understood. You use that judgement to decide when to stop studying or whether to re-read. The 2021 experiment above did not find this calibration difference, so the evidence is mixed, but a quick self-test after screen reading costs little.
Is the gap closing as screens improve?
The evidence disagrees on this. Delgado's review found that the paper advantage increased in more recent studies rather than shrinking, which is the opposite of what you might expect as screens got sharper. Kong's smaller review saw a trend in the other direction, a gap that seemed to be narrowing after 2013, but it was not statistically significant. Neither review can say why. Possible explanations include changes in how people habitually read on screens and changes in which studies get published, but these are guesses.
Does a tablet or e-reader help?
Yes, somewhat. Most studies in the earlier reviews used computer screens. The 2024 handheld-device review ran two separate meta-analyses of tablets and e-readers against print. It still found a significant paper advantage, but a smaller one: 0.113 in studies that compared different groups of readers (38 effect sizes) and 0.103 in studies where the same people read in both formats (21 effect sizes).
How much paper beats screens on comprehension
Show the numbers
| Mostly computers (2018) | 0.2 (54 studies) |
|---|---|
| Handheld, different readers | 0.1 (38 effect sizes) |
| Handheld, same readers | 0.1 (21 effect sizes) |
The same review found that tablets and e-readers were equally good for comprehension, so if you are choosing between an e-ink reader and an iPad, comprehension should not decide it. The authors had expected tablets to do worse, because they are built for apps and quick switching rather than reading, and their data did not support that expectation. The screen deficit was larger for undergraduates than for school pupils, and for people tested individually rather than in groups.
A 2013 study in PLOS ONE by Kretzschmar and colleagues found a gap between preference and effort. Young and older adults read on paper, an e-reader and a backlit tablet while their eye movements and brain activity were recorded. Almost everyone said they preferred paper, and comprehension did not differ between the three. But older readers showed signs of less effort on the tablet, which the authors put down to its higher contrast.
None of these reviews tested notifications, and lab experiments usually strip them out, so the real-world difference between a phone that pings and a basic e-ink reader may be larger than any of these figures. That is a reasonable inference, not a measured result.
What this means for children
For young children, the research is split by what the digital book does. Furenes, Kucirkova and Bus (2021), in Review of Educational Research, pooled 39 studies of 1,812 children aged one to eight. They found that:
- A plain e-book loses. Digital books that differed from print only by being on a screen led to lower story comprehension.
- Enhancements that fit the story win. Digital books with features matched to the story, such as animations that illustrate what is happening, outperformed paper books.
- An adult reading aloud wins too. An adult reading a paper book with a child worked better than a child reading an enhanced e-book alone.
- Dictionaries are mixed. Built-in dictionaries had no effect, or a negative one, on comprehension, but did help children learn words.
For older pupils, the question is habits rather than single sessions. A 2025 meta-analysis by Altamura, Vargas and Salmerón, covering 469,564 participants in studies from 2000 to 2022, found that leisure digital reading habits had only a small link with comprehension (r = 0.055), much smaller than the medium-sized link found in earlier research on print reading habits. The link was negative in primary and middle school and turned positive in high school and university. These are correlations, so they cannot show that digital reading causes weaker comprehension in younger children.
The OECD's 21st-Century Readers report on PISA 2018 points the same way. Across OECD countries, 15-year-olds who read books mostly in print scored 49 points higher in reading than those who rarely or never read books, while those who read mostly digitally scored 15 points higher, after accounting for socio-economic background and gender. Again this is an association: children who choose paper books may differ in other ways too.
If you are deciding what to hand a young child, print read together is the safest default, and a good digital book is a reasonable supplement rather than a hazard. For broader limits by age, see screen time by age.
How to read better on a screen
None of these steps has been tested as a package. They follow from the patterns above.
- Print what matters most. For dense material you need to remember, such as course reading, a contract or medical information, paper has the clearest advantage.
- Do not rush screen reading. The gap was largest under time pressure. If you have a deadline, give yourself more time on screen than you think you need, or switch to paper.
- Test yourself afterwards. Because readers tend to overrate what they took in from a screen, close the text and write down the three main points before deciding you are done.
- Use a reading device or a reading mode. A basic e-ink reader has almost nothing to interrupt you with. On a phone or tablet, silence everything while you read. On iPhone, go to Settings > Focus, tap the plus sign, choose Reading, and allow no apps. On Pixel and many other Android phones, go to Settings > Digital Wellbeing & parental controls > Focus mode and pause your distracting apps (on recent Android versions this may sit under Settings > Modes; menus vary by manufacturer).
- Stories are fine on any screen. For novels, the format makes little measurable difference, so read where you will actually read.
- Keep the room quiet as well. Background sound has its own cost to comprehension, covered in does music help you focus.
If your reading happens while you study, how to study without phone distraction covers the rest of the set-up.
Common questions
Is reading on a Kindle as good as reading a paper book?
Nearly. The 2024 review found a small paper advantage on handheld devices, about half the size of the earlier, mostly computer-based estimate, and no difference between e-readers and tablets. One study found Kindle readers were worse at reconstructing the order of a plot, but it was small.
Is reading on your phone bad for comprehension?
Slightly worse than paper for informational text, according to the meta-analyses, and the gap grows if you rush. Phones also carry notifications, which lab studies usually remove, so the everyday cost may be larger than the measured one.
Do people read faster on paper or on a screen?
No reliable difference. Both the 2018 Kong review and the 2019 Clinton review found no significant difference in reading speed or time.
Are e-books bad for young children?
Plain e-books led to lower story comprehension than print in a 2021 review of 39 studies, but e-books with enhancements that matched the story did better than paper. An adult reading a print book with the child beat a child reading an enhanced e-book alone.
When to get more help
If reading on any medium gives you headaches, blurred vision or tired eyes, see an optician; screens make eye strain more noticeable, and the 20-20-20 rule helps with the routine part. If a child is struggling to read in any format, talk to their teacher or the school's special educational needs co-ordinator (SENCo), or your GP, rather than blaming the device; the NHS has guidance on dyslexia, and switching to paper will not solve a reading difficulty on its own.
sources for this page
- Don't throw away your printed books: A meta-analysis on the effects of reading media on reading comprehensionEducational Research Review · 2018 · 54 studies, 171,055 participants, 2000 to 2017 · Small effect; most participants come from a few large studies, and most screens were computers rather than handheld devices.
- Reading from paper compared to screens: A systematic review and meta-analysisJournal of Research in Reading · 2019 · 33 studies with random assignment · Subgroup effect sizes were not checked against the full text, so only the direction of each finding is reported here.
- Comparison of reading performance on screen and on paper: A meta-analysisComputers & Education · 2018 · 17 studies, 2000 to 2016 · Small number of studies; its shrinking-gap trend was not statistically significant.
- Reading comprehension on handheld devices versus on paper: A narrative review and meta-analysis of the medium effect and its moderatorsJournal of Educational Psychology · 2024 · Two meta-analyses (negative g = screen worse): g = -0.113 across 38 between-participant effect sizes and g = -0.103 across 21 within-participant effect sizes · Few studies used e-readers (six, against 13 for tablets), so the tablet and e-reader comparison rests on limited data. The larger deficit for undergraduates and for individually tested readers, and the authors' expectation that tablets would do worse, are from the paper's abstract and discussion. Compared with the 2018 review, it pools different studies.
- Comparing Comprehension of a Long Text Read in Print Book and on Kindle: Where in the Text and When in the Story?Frontiers in Psychology · 2019 · 50 adults, one 28-page story of about 10,800 words; time and sequence questions 57.1% correct in print against 44.0% on Kindle · Small sample, one text and an older Kindle model.
- The inattentive on-screen reading: Reading medium affects attention and reading comprehension under time pressureLearning and Instruction · 2021 · 140 undergraduates · One experiment with university students; details taken from the published abstract.
- Subjective impressions do not mirror online reading effort: Concurrent EEG-eyetracking evidence from the reading of books and digital mediaPLOS ONE · 2013 · Young and older adults reading on paper, an e-reader and a backlit tablet, with eye-tracking and EEG · Measured reading effort rather than deep comprehension; older devices.
- A Comparison of Children's Reading on Paper Versus Screen: A Meta-AnalysisReview of Educational Research · 2021 · 39 studies, 1,812 children aged 1 to 8 · Results depend heavily on how each digital book was designed.
- Do New Forms of Reading Pay Off? A Meta-Analysis on the Relationship Between Leisure Digital Reading Habits and Text ComprehensionReview of Educational Research · 2025 · 40 effect sizes, 469,564 participants, 2000 to 2022; overall r = 0.055 · Correlational: shows association rather than cause.
- 21st-Century Readers: Developing Literacy Skills in a Digital WorldOECD (PISA 2018) · 2021 · 15-year-olds in PISA 2018; mostly-print book readers +49 points and mostly-digital +15 points against those who rarely or never read books (OECD averages) · Correlational; figures are OECD averages adjusted for socio-economic status and gender, taken from the OECD's summary and country notes.
- DyslexiaNHS · 2026 · Signposting for help, not evidence on reading formats.