Habits / does-habit-stacking-work

Does Habit Stacking Work? What the Research Shows

10 min readchecked

Habit stacking probably helps, though not because the old habit carries the new one along, as is usually claimed, and the direct evidence for it is thin. The method links a new behaviour to something you already do every day: "after I pour my morning coffee, I will read one page". The best support for it comes from research on if-then plans, which consistently help people follow through on what they intended. Only a handful of small trials have tested anchoring a new habit to an existing routine specifically, and their results are mixed.

In the largest of those trials, linking a new eating habit to a daily routine worked about as well as linking it to a set time of day. What predicted a lasting habit was how often people actually did the new behaviour. So the "stack" itself is less important than having a clear, frequent cue and repeating the behaviour when it comes. For phone habits there is an extra catch: one 2025 trial found that making plans alone did not reduce measured screen time.

What is habit stacking?

Habit stacking means attaching a new behaviour to a habit you already have, so the old habit acts as a reminder for the new one. The usual formula is "after [current habit], I will [new habit]". Examples include "after I brush my teeth, I will floss" or "after I plug my phone in at night, I will pick up my book".

The idea is that you do not have to remember the new behaviour. The existing routine happens anyway, and over time the new behaviour starts to follow it without a decision. That is close to how psychologists define a habit: a response triggered automatically by a situation you meet often.

Where the idea came from

James Clear's 2018 book Atomic Habits made the term well known. On his own page about the method, Clear credits the approach to the Stanford behaviour scientist BJ Fogg, who calls it "anchoring" in his Tiny Habits programme, and says the name itself came from S.J. Scott's 2014 book Habit Stacking. Several popular articles say Clear coined it. By his own account he did not.

Fogg's version adds two steps: make the new behaviour tiny (one push-up, one flossed tooth) and "celebrate" straight after it to create a positive feeling. Neither book is a study, and neither presents trial evidence for stacking as such. In an April 2026 Washington Post piece reposted by the Association for Psychological Science, the Wharton behavioural scientist Katy Milkman said there was "hardly any research" on habit stacking despite how widely it is used.

What the research actually tests

Two separate bodies of research bear on habit stacking. One is large and supportive but tests something broader. The other tests stacking directly but is small.

If-then plans: strong evidence for the underlying idea

Psychologists would class a habit stack as an implementation intention: a plan that names a situation and what you will do when it arrives. "If it is 7 pm, I will go for a run" is one; "after dinner, I will go for a run" is another.

These plans have been tested many times. A 2006 meta-analysis in Advances in Experimental Social Psychology by Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled 94 tests and found a medium-to-large effect on reaching goals (d = 0.65). A much larger 2025 meta-analysis in the European Review of Social Psychology by Sheeran, Olivia Listrom and Gollwitzer covered 642 tests and found the plans worked across behavioural, cognitive and emotional outcomes, with effect sizes from 0.27 to 0.66. Effects were larger when the plan used a strict if-then format, when people were highly motivated, and when they rehearsed the plan.

That is good evidence that deciding in advance "when this happens, I will do that" helps. It is not evidence that tying the plan to an existing habit beats tying it to a time or a place, because most of those studies did not compare the two.

Anchoring to a routine: a few small trials

The studies that compared anchors directly are few, and they disagree.

  • Flossing after brushing, first trial. In a 2013 exploratory study in the British Journal of Health Psychology, Gaby Judah, Benjamin Gardner and Robert Aunger gave 50 people the same motivational message about flossing and told half to floss before brushing their teeth and half after. At the eight-month follow-up, those who flossed after brushing had stronger habits and flossed more often. Flossing was self-reported, and the sample was small. This is the study most articles on habit stacking point to, usually without naming it.
  • Flossing after brushing, second trial. Judah repeated the comparison with 118 members of the public as part of her 2015 PhD at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine. This time, neither flossing nor automaticity was affected by whether people flossed before or after brushing.
  • Routine versus clock time. A 2021 randomised trial in the British Journal of Health Psychology by Jan Keller and colleagues assigned 192 adults aged 18 to 77 to link a new eating habit either to an existing daily routine or to a set time. Over 84 days of daily check-ins, both groups became more automatic and the trial found no difference between them. Among people who formed a habit, it took a median of 59 days to peak. The strongest predictor of a habit was how often people carried out their plan.

Taken together, the trials suggest an existing routine works as a cue about as well as a fixed time, and that repetition matters more than either.

Why repetition matters more than the anchor

Habits form slowly, whatever cue you choose. The 59-day median in the 2021 trial is close to the 66 days found in the best-known study of habit formation, led by Phillippa Lally at University College London, in which individual times ranged from 18 to 254 days. How long it takes to break a habit goes through those timing studies, and why the popular 21 days has no research behind it.

What a routine cue can do is make repetition easier. A daily routine happens at roughly the same point every day, so it gives you a reliable chance to do the new behaviour. That only helps if the anchor is something you do every day, at a fairly fixed point, and if the new behaviour is small enough to do every time. An anchor you skip at weekends, or a new habit that takes twenty minutes, gives you fewer repetitions and a slower habit.

Does habit stacking help you use your phone less?

The evidence is limited, and the one large trial is discouraging. In the one study that filmed it, people started phone use themselves far more often than notifications did, which makes cues worth working on. But planning on its own has not been shown to cut screen time.

What started each phone interaction

025507510089%Started by the user11%Prompted by a notification
Share of 1,130 smartphone interactions filmed with wearable cameras worn by 37 people. The 11% is the remainder the study attributes to notifications. Source: Why are smartphones disruptive?, Computers in Human Behavior (2021): 37 users, 1,130 interactions.
Show the numbers
What started each phone interaction: underlying values
Started by the user89%
Prompted by a notification11%

A 2021 study in Computers in Human Behavior by Maxi Heitmayer and Saadi Lahlou at the London School of Economics filmed 37 people's phone use with small wearable cameras, about 200 hours of footage covering 1,130 interactions. In 89% of them, the user picked up the phone without a notification prompting it. The authors concluded that the disruption comes from learned behaviour rather than the device. It is a small sample, but it fits the research on why you keep checking your phone: idle moments act as cues.

Two trials have tested if-then plans on phone use:

  • Plans worked where people applied them. In a 2021 randomised trial in Transportation Research Part F, Mark Elliott and colleagues at the University of Strathclyde had 136 drivers form if-then plans for not using their phones in specific driving situations. A month later, the planning group reported using their phones less often in the situations they had planned for, but not in other driving situations. Use was self-reported. For the wider problem, see how to stop texting while driving.
  • Plans alone did not reduce screen time. In a preregistered 2025 trial in Computers in Human Behavior, Lina Brockmeier, Jan Keller and colleagues randomly assigned 787 students to make up to three action plans and three coping plans for cutting their phone use, or to a control group. Over three weeks of objectively measured use, the plans had no significant effect on total smartphone usage time.

A plan covers the moments it names, and phone use is spread across dozens of moments a day. So the stacks most likely to help with phone habits are probably ones that change the setting at a fixed point, such as where the phone goes at night, rather than ones that rely on willpower each time you feel the pull. No trial has compared the two.

How to use habit stacking to change a phone habit

This is how to apply the research above. No trial has tested this exact routine, so treat it as a starting point and adjust it.

  1. Pick an anchor you never skip. Good anchors happen once a day at a fixed point: putting the kettle on in the morning, locking the front door when you get home, brushing your teeth at night.
  2. Attach an action that moves or limits the phone. "After I lock the front door, I will put my phone on the hall shelf" changes the setting for the whole evening. That is likely to work better than "after dinner, I will not scroll", because it does not ask for restraint every time.
  3. Keep the new behaviour tiny. Charging the phone outside the bedroom takes seconds. Making a phone-free bedroom work covers the alarm clock and the other practical problems.
  4. Write it as a strict if-then sentence. The 2025 meta-analysis found plans in an if-then format worked better than looser ones. Write it down and read it back a few times.
  5. Count repetitions, not days. Missing one day made no lasting difference in Lally's study. If you want to see whether the change is working, compare weekly totals with a baseline week using the free screen time tracker.

Once the phone is down, let a setting carry the plan:

  • iPhone — Settings > Focus > Sleep lets you set a schedule that silences notifications and dims the Lock Screen at a fixed time each night.
  • Android (Pixel) — Settings > Modes > Bedtime silences the phone and can turn the screen grey on a schedule. On older Pixel software it sits under Settings > Digital Wellbeing & parental controls > Bedtime mode.
  • Android (Samsung) — Settings > Modes and Routines > Modes > Sleep does the same on Galaxy phones.

Stacks that start a good habit work the same way. "After I put the phone on the hall shelf, I will read one page" uses the first change as the anchor for the next. If reading feels harder than it used to, see how to read books again.

Some habit-stacking advice goes further than the research.

  • "Celebrate to wire in the habit." Fogg's Tiny Habits method asks you to celebrate right after the new behaviour. No published study appears to have tested the celebration step on its own. In a 2022 randomised trial in Frontiers in Public Health, 154 adults took the free five-day Tiny Habits programme aimed at gratitude, the same programme aimed at other habits, or nothing. Both Tiny Habits groups reported more gratitude straight afterwards, and at one month the gratitude group still differed from the control group. But only 58% of participants completed the one-month follow-up, with fewer staying in the Tiny Habits groups, and celebration is built into the Tiny Habits method both groups used, so its effect cannot be separated.
  • "Stack it and it becomes automatic in a few weeks." The studies above found the median time to a habit was around two months, and much longer for many people.
  • "After is better than before." The first flossing study found that; the second did not.

Common questions

Is habit stacking the same as an implementation intention?

It is a type of one. An implementation intention is any plan of the form "when this happens, I will do that". Habit stacking uses an existing habit as the "when". The research behind implementation intentions is large; the research on using a habit as the cue is small.

How many habits can you stack at once?

No study has tested a limit. The trials above each added one behaviour. If you want to try more, the evidence on repetition suggests adding one at a time and waiting until the first feels automatic.

Can habit stacking break a bad habit?

It can help by putting a new response where the old one used to go, which is how habit researchers often suggest replacing one. For phone habits, the stacks most likely to help are the ones that move the phone out of reach at a fixed point in the day. Planning alone did not reduce screen time in the one large trial.

When to see a GP

Habit stacking is a low-risk thing to try, and if it does not work the likeliest fix is a different cue or a smaller behaviour. Speak to your GP if your phone use feels out of your control, keeps you awake, or is harming your work, studies or relationships, or if it is tied to gambling. The same applies if heavy use comes with low mood or anxiety, because the phone may be how you are coping with something that needs its own help. A GP can talk it through and, if useful, refer you to NHS talking therapies such as cognitive behavioural therapy.

Advertisement

sources for this page

  1. How to Use Habit-Stacking to Reach Your Health and Wellness GoalsAssociation for Psychological Science (reposting The Washington Post) · 2026 · Journalism, not a study; source of Katy Milkman's comment on the evidence.
  2. Habit Stacking: How to Build New Habits by Taking Advantage of Old OnesJames Clear (author's website) · 2014 · Author's own page; credits the method to BJ Fogg and the name to S.J. Scott, and cites no trial of stacking itself.
  3. Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processesAdvances in Experimental Social Psychology · 2006 · 94 independent tests · Covers goal attainment in general, not habit formation or routine-based cues specifically.
  4. The when and how of planning: Meta-analysis of the scope and components of implementation intentions in 642 testsEuropean Review of Social Psychology · 2025 · 642 independent tests · Effect sizes vary by outcome type; most included studies did not compare routine cues with time or place cues.
  5. Forming a flossing habit: an exploratory study of the psychological determinants of habit formationBritish Journal of Health Psychology · 2013 · 50 adults, 8-month follow-up · Exploratory, small sample, self-reported flossing.
  6. An Investigation into the Psychological Determinants of Health Habit Formation (PhD thesis)London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine · 2015 · 118 members of the public · Doctoral thesis rather than a journal article; found no effect of flossing before or after brushing.
  7. Habit formation following routine-based versus time-based cue planning: A randomized controlled trialBritish Journal of Health Psychology · 2021 · 192 adults aged 18 to 77, 84 days · Nutrition behaviours only; automaticity was self-reported.
  8. How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real worldEuropean Journal of Social Psychology · 2010 · 96 volunteers over 84 days · The 66-day median comes from the 39 participants whose data fitted the model well.
  9. Why are smartphones disruptive? An empirical study of smartphone use in real-life contextsComputers in Human Behavior · 2021 · 37 users, about 200 hours of footage, 1,130 interactions · Small sample filmed with wearable cameras; not designed to test any intervention.
  10. Evidence that implementation intentions reduce drivers' use of mobile phones while drivingTransportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour · 2021 · 136 drivers, one-month follow-up · Phone use was self-reported; effect limited to the situations people planned for.
  11. Planning a digital detox: Findings from a randomized controlled trial to reduce smartphone usage timeComputers in Human Behavior · 2025 · 787 students, 3 weeks of objectively measured use · Student sample and short follow-up; tested action and coping plans, not habit stacks as such.
  12. Tiny Habits for Gratitude: Implications for Healthcare Education StakeholdersFrontiers in Public Health · 2022 · 154 adults in three groups · Only 58% completed the one-month follow-up; self-reported outcomes; the celebration step was not tested separately.
  13. NHS talking therapiesNHS · 2025 · Health service guidance rather than a study.